Demystifying Marketing Attribution: A Framework for B2B SaaS Success (HubSpot Edition)

B2B SaaS marketers constantly face the pressure of proving ROI. Boardrooms are filled with questions like "What's the return on investment (ROI) of this campaign?" or "How many demo requests did the last campaign generate?" Answering these questions can be tricky, especially in B2B SaaS where the buying journey is complex and ad spend rarely translates directly into demo requests.

While some campaigns generate direct leads, most nurture demand over time. The limitations of current marketing measurement technologies further complicate things. However, despair not! This blog post will outline a framework for B2B SaaS marketers to move beyond vanity metrics and gain valuable insights into marketing performance.

The Dark Funnel: Beyond Measuring Every Click

Marketers are often tempted to analyze every single dollar spent on advertising. However, this approach is not only inefficient but also ultimately futile. Obsessing over every click creates analysis paralysis and hinders your ability to make strategic decisions. Sometimes, good marketing is simply about building brand awareness and creating compelling narratives, not directly tracking every interaction.

Beyond Vanity Metrics: KPIs that Matter Most

Executives and investors crave data-driven insights. A robust framework is essential for providing actionable feedback beyond vanity metrics like impressions, clicks, and even conversions. Here's how to move beyond the surface level and gain a deeper understanding of marketing effectiveness:

Tracking the Right Impressions: Why LinkedIn Matters

LinkedIn's treasure trove of B2B data offers invaluable insights into your target audience. Features like Sales Insights (launched 2021) and detailed campaign performance data (hopefully available through future integrations or APIs as well soon enough, not just Salesforce) can be game-changers for B2B SaaS marketers. The most valuable insight? Honestly, Impression Share provides a powerful indicator of brand awareness within your target market.

Tracking the Right Clicks: IP Unmasking Tools

Several tools like Leadfeeder, Albacross, and Lead Forensics can help you understand which companies visit your website. These vendors leverage databases of IP addresses to identify website visitors. By segmenting this data based on UTM parameters, you can identify which campaigns are driving traffic and convert those high-intent visitors into leads (even if they don't fill out a form). Consider "time on page" or "average session duration" as additional filters to identify truly engaged visitors. This data, synced with your CRM via integrations or APIs, allows for targeted sales development outreach to qualified leads.

Tracking the Right Conversions: The Power of CDPs

Customer Data Platforms (CDPs) are another valuable tool for B2B SaaS marketers. While some CDPs cater primarily to B2C audiences (e.g., Emarsys and Exponea/Bloomreach), others, like HubSpot and Segment, focus on B2B needs. Most CDPs rely on cookie-based data, but since this is first-party data, it's less susceptible to Google's upcoming privacy updates (which primarily impact third-party cookies).

Marketing Attribution: Salesforce vs HubSpot Campaigns

Let's explore existing marketing attribution models within popular CRM platforms.

Salesforce Campaign Attribution: Caveats and Considerations

Salesforce Campaigns offer a seemingly straightforward solution for marketing attribution. However, there are some limitations to consider:

  • Limited Attribution Models: While Salesforce offers models like U-shaped, W-shaped, time-decay, and last interaction, these models may not provide the granularity B2B SaaS marketers need.
  • Contact-Based Attribution: Salesforce attribution focuses on contacts, not accounts. This can be problematic for B2B marketing strategies that involve Account-Based Marketing (ABM) tactics.

For more details on Salesforce attribution models, you can refer to the resources linked in the original blog post.

HubSpot Campaign Attribution: Understanding Its Limitations

HubSpot's campaign attribution models also have their limitations, as detailed in their "Influenced Deals" section of the Campaigns FAQs. HubSpot's focus on marketing assets and content can be valuable, but it's important to understand its limitations:

  • Limited to Closed-Won Deals: HubSpot attribution only tracks closed-won deals and contacts assigned to deals.
  • No Retroactive Data Updates: Campaign membership data cannot be retroactively updated, meaning touches from non-member campaigns may be missed.

Marketing Automation Setup: Putting Data into Action

Now that we have valuable data, it's time to make it actionable. Here's a breakdown of online and offline marketing automation setups:

Online Marketing Automation

  • UTM Parameters: The cornerstone of online marketing attribution, UTM parameters allow you to track campaign performance. By including UTM parameters in your campaigns, tools like Leadfeeder, HubSpot, and IP unmasking tools can identify campaign-driven traffic and flag relevant contacts and companies.
  • Forms: While UTM parameters track website visitors, forms capture valuable lead information. By strategically designing forms to capture content asset preferences (demos, videos, etc.), you gain deeper insights into user intent.
  • Workflows: Marketing automation platforms allow you to create workflows triggered by specific actions. For example, a workflow might be triggered when a visitor downloads a white paper, automatically adding them to a nurture sequence. These workflows can be customized for contacts, companies, and deals.

Here's a simplified example of a templated online marketing automation approach:

  1. Define Campaigns: Establish clear campaign goals and target audiences.
  2. Set UTMs: Assign unique UTM parameters to each campaign.
  3. Create Workflows: Develop workflows for contacts, companies, and deals based on specific actions (e.g., form submissions, website visits).

This approach allows for automated lead nurturing and efficient marketing campaign management.

Offline Marketing Automation

Offline marketing efforts also require data tracking. A common approach is to utilize a flag for syncs/uploads, with "Last Lead Source" as the primary indicator. Contacts, companies, and deals can be tagged, triggering workflows similar to the online approach, often facilitated by integration tools like Zapier.

Key Reports & Definitions: Moving Beyond Vanity Metrics

Marketing teams are often bombarded with demands to "create more opportunities," "build more pipeline," or "generate more revenue." However, what do these terms truly mean in the context of B2B SaaS marketing attribution? Let's break down some key metrics and their definitions:

10 Scaleup Challenges

Marketing Sourced Deals: Defining "Sourced"

Demo requests are a common indicator of marketing-generated leads. However, not all demo requests can be solely attributed to marketing efforts. Sales development or outbound sales teams might have nurtured the account beforehand.

A time-based approach is recommended for attribution. When did the marketing touchpoint occur in relation to other interactions (sales outreach, lifecycle stage, etc.)?

Here's a breakdown of key metrics for marketing attribution:

Accounts Being Worked (SAL):

These are accounts identified and nurtured by marketing that are now actively pursued by the sales team. This indicates a good fit for the product/service.

Engaged Accounts (SQL):

These are accounts where sales representatives have established contact with relevant decision-makers and are working towards securing a meeting. This provides valuable insight into the effectiveness of business development efforts.

Marketing Sourced Deals 

"Demo Meeting" - These are opportunities that progress to a demo meeting (or similar significant next step) after a marketing touchpoint. This attribution window typically has a set timeframe (e.g., 30 days) to account for the complex B2B sales cycle.

Marketing touches can include content downloads, webinar registrations, event participation, and yes, even demo requests.

If marketing played any role in bringing the account in (regardless of prior sales touches), it should be considered "sourced" by marketing.

Remember: Sales plays a must-do role in nurturing leads and closing deals. Marketing attribution is about understanding how marketing efforts contribute to the overall sales funnel.

Here's the key takeaway: By utilizing a time-based approach and considering the full sales cycle, you can gain a clearer picture of how marketing efforts generate new and qualified leads that ultimately become opportunities.